[On one hand Peter does want to keep her within eyesight. It's her parent's place but he's an untrusting soul at time even in the safest of spaces. Evangeline has given him no reason though to not trust her alone with her father -- it's not like she's kidnapped and he's trying to keep her from telling anyone after all.

He tries to keep the moment of unease stuffed down with a sheepish smile, patting her shoulder.]

Trust me, you don't want me anywhere near the kitchen. We'll be fine out here.

[He looks to Sara now.]

Unless you want to go help too? I'll be honest here, I'm useless in the kitchen.